I actually finished Halo 3 a long time ago...like when it came out, but I'm just now getting around to writing about it.
Halo 3 (360) - 6.5/10 "Decent"
Pros
- Lots of multi-player options
- Good Music
- It's pretty fun driving the Warthog
Cons
- Story is weak
- Tons of idiots online
- Not much to offer for those who don't like multi-player
Grand Theft Auto 4 (PS3) - 9/10 "Highly Recommended"
Pros
- Great graphics
- Good story
- Liberty City really feels alive
Cons
- Radio shows are too short
- No Rhino
- Car handling takes a little getting used to
Metal Gear Solid 4 (PS3) - 8.5/10 "Highly Recommended"
Pros
- Great graphics and animation
- Great story
- Lot of unlockables and extras
Cons
- Weakest story out of all the MGS games
- Essentially the same boss battle mechanics from previous games
- Story is complex, even for Metal Gear veterans
Shadow of the Colossus (PS2) - 9.5/10 "Superb"
Pros
- Terrific story
- Amazing Graphics, Animation and Music
- Boss battles are extremely fun and feel very cinematic
Cons
- Too easy
- It eventually ends...
- Some of the Time Trials are a bit strict
ICO (PS2) - 8/10 " Recommended"
Pros
- Great Story
- Some interesting puzzles
- The ending theme song ;)
Cons
- Too short
- No replay value...(The NTSC version is stripped of any extras)
- No progressive or widescreen support
I actually finished Halo 3 a long time ago...like when it came out, but I'm just now getting around to writing about it.
Also, I wrote a full review of MGS4 a while ago, which you can read here.
Shadow of the Colossus is one of my favorite games of all time....so I can't say enough good things about it.